For fans on the hunt for a TV show like Warrior Nun, there’s a supernatural action series out there that offers a very similar feel, one that ran for four full seasons without a controversial cancellation cutting the story prematurely. Warrior Nun may have built a cult following with its fierce female lead, celestial mythology, and high-stakes battles between good and evil, but it left fans hanging far too soon. Luckily, there’s another show that blends comic book-style fantasy, fast-paced demon hunting, and complicated legacy-driven heroines – and this one actually got the chance to tell its story properly.
While Warrior Nun became a sleeper hit on Netflix thanks to its gritty tone and genre-mashing story, the show was cut short just as things were heating up. Still, for fans of ancient prophecies, cursed lineages, and weapon-wielding women going toe-to-toe with demonic foes, the supernatural TV landscape isn’t totally barren. There’s a series out there that ticks all the same boxes, and then some. Packed with snark, sisterhood, and shootouts, it’s the kind of show that delivers both the monster-of-the-week action and the emotionally charged arcs that Warrior Nun fans crave.
Wynonna Earp Is A Supernatural Fantasy Series Based On A Comic Book
The Cult Syfy Hit Offers Everything From Demon Hunting To Destiny-Driven Heroines
While a series filled with six-shooters and grizzled ghosts from the Old West ever doesn’t seem like a TV show like Warrior Nun on the surface, Wynonna Earp is a solid spiritual successor. Wynonna Earp is a supernatural Western-fantasy TV series that aired from 2016 to 2021, running for four seasons. Based on the comic books by Beau Smith, Wyonna Earp first premiered on Syfy and quickly gained a devoted following. The series follows Wynonna (Melanie Scrofano), the great-great-granddaughter of legendary gunslinger Wyatt Earp, who inherits a cursed gun and an even more cursed job. Thanks to her lineage, it’s now down to Wyonna to send resurrected outlaws back to hell.
At a glance, Wynonna Earp might look like just another supernatural show, but dig a little deeper, and it becomes clear why it’s such a good fit for anyone searching for a TV show like Warrior Nun. Both series follow reluctant female heroes who are chosen by fate and armed with holy relics (Wynonna’s Peacemaker, Ava’s halo) to fight demonic enemies. They also blend fast-paced action with emotional character arcs, especially when it comes to sisterhood and trauma.
Wynonna Earp brings the same kind of gritty yet hopeful tone that made Warrior Nun such a standout.
What sets Wynonna Earp apart – and what will appeal to Warrior Nun fans – is how it leans into its genre roots without ever losing its heart. Just like Ava Silva, Wynonna is deeply flawed, incredibly funny, and constantly grappling with the weight of her legacy. She’s not a traditional hero, and that makes her all the more compelling. The show also doesn’t skimp on world-building, offering everything from supernatural cults to cursed towns and time-traveling villains.
Wynonna Earp is chaotic in the best way possible, yet somehow manages to hit many of the same notes as Warrior Nun. With a core cast that develops strong bonds over time and arcs that tackle redemption, destiny, and loss, Wynonna Earp brings the same kind of gritty yet hopeful tone that made Warrior Nun such a standout.
Wynonna Earp’s Larger-Than-Life Premise Makes It Perfect For Warrior Nun Fans
Demon-Slaying, Destiny, And Complicated Heroines Collide In This Supernatural Gem
At the heart of both Warrior Nun and Wynonna Earp is a very specific kind of protagonist – one who’s dragged into a war they didn’t ask for, only to discover they’re uniquely equipped to win it. In Warrior Nun, Ava starts off as a paraplegic orphan who wakes up with supernatural powers and becomes the centerpiece of an ancient war. In Wynonna Earp, Wynonna returns to her cursed hometown only to find she’s the latest in a bloodline tasked with hunting down the resurrected souls of outlaws. Both shows use this premise to explore big ideas – faith, legacy, free will – through the lens of ass-kicking heroines who’d rather do anything else than be the “chosen one.”
This reluctant savior angle is just one of many parallels that make Wynonna Earp a great show like Warrior Nun. Both series blend horror-fantasy with comic book energy, mixing gunfights, exorcisms, and sacred relics with snappy dialogue and offbeat humor. Fans of Warrior Nun will feel right at home with Wynonna Earp’s monster-of-the-week format, which never sacrifices character development for spectacle. Like Ava, Wynonna grows over time – from a booze-soaked cynic to a fiercely loyal protector of her found family.
The sisterhood element is also front and center. While Warrior Nun emphasized the bond between Ava and the other warrior nuns (especially Beatrice), Wynonna Earp builds its emotional core around the relationship between Wynonna and her brilliant younger sister, Waverly. Their connection anchors the show, much like Ava and Beatrice’s evolving relationship does in Warrior Nun. And for those who appreciated the queer representation in Warrior Nun, Wynonna Earp was ahead of the curve. Waverly’s relationship with officer Nicole Haught (aka WayHaught) became a genre-defining romance – one that was never sidelined or used as bait.
Even stylistically, Warrior Nun and Wynonna Earp have similar energy. Both love leaning into stylized action, cinematic flashbacks, and mythological twists that challenge the characters’ beliefs. Each series manages to feel both grounded and surreal, with small-scale, personal stakes that escalate into epic, supernatural battles. What’s more, both shows walk the tightrope of irreverence and reverence, joking about demons while still treating their worlds with emotional sincerity.
Sadly, Warrior Nun Didn’t Get To Have Nearly As Many Episodes As Wynonna Earp
The Supernatural Journey Lasted Far Longer For Wynonna Earp Fans
Despite its growing fanbase and the massive online #SaveWarriorNun campaign, Warrior Nun was canceled by Netflix after just two seasons – a gut punch for fans who had invested in the story and its characters. The show left off with major cliffhangers and unresolved arcs, especially around Ava’s fate and her relationship with Beatrice. While there’s a movie trilogy in the works to wrap things up, it’s no substitute for what could have been a long-running, genre-defining series.
That’s where Wynonna Earp comes in – not only does it hit the same genre notes, but it also had the luxury of time Warrior Nun never had the chance to experience. With four full seasons and nearly 50 episodes, Wynonna Earp actually got to explore its mythology, grow its characters, and tie off major storylines. Fans didn’t have to rely on hope or hashtags to see their favorite arcs play out. That level of narrative closure is rare in genre TV, and it’s exactly what many Warrior Nun fans were denied.
Related
Wynonna Earp: Wayhaught Explained (& Why It’s One Of TV’s Most Important Relationships)
Wynonna Earp follows a demon-fighting descendant gunslinger but the relationships in the show, like the popular Wayhaught, are just as important.
The comparison is especially painful because both shows built their success off passionate fan communities, strong queer representation, and genre-blending originality. Yet only one of them got the room to fully breathe. For anyone who felt short-changed by the abrupt ending of Warrior Nun, diving into Wynonna Earp offers a way to recapture that same magic, with the added bonus of knowing you’ll actually get an ending.
For fans desperate to find a TV show like Warrior Nun, Wynonna Earp isn’t just a temporary fix. It’s a full-fledged replacement, one that honors the same themes, the same underdog energy, and the same kind of emotionally rich, demon-fueled storytelling – only this time, with a lot more episodes to love.
- Release Date
-
2020 – 2021
- Network
-
Netflix
- Showrunner
-
Simon Barry
- Directors
-
Simon Barry
- Writers
-
Simon Barry
