6 Best Men’s Shaving Creams for Sensitive Skin in 2024

If you’re a guy with sensitive skin, then you need to read this article.

There’s almost nothing worse than shaving when you’re susceptible to bumps, burns, and bruising from the razor blades.

It just hurts.

Shaving cream makes it easier, especially for “high-maintenance” faces, as it lubricates the skin to provide a smoother ride. Think of shaving cream as a protective barrier.

Good creams also hydrate the skin and enrich your hair to contribute to an overall healthier complexion.

So, I found the best men’s shaving creams for sensitive skin so that you can say goodbye to cuts and hello to smooth sailing. Keep reading to solve your shaving woes.

Key Takeaways

When rounding up the best men’s shaving creams for sensitive skin, I scanned through a plethora of brands, Amazon products, and user reviews. The six below are the best products I found based on ingredients, consistency, and scent.

My top spot goes to the Edge Store Shave Gel for its refreshing scent and protective ingredients. It’s followed by the affordable NIVEA Men Sensitive Shave Gel, which is alcohol-free and creates a thick, rich lather that all men will love.

Why it’s great: The best shaving cream for men’s sensitive skin should do more than just help the razor glide smoothly down your beard. It should also come with some extra benefits specifically for sensitive skin. The Edge Store Shave Gel for Men has exactly that.

It’s formulated with aloe and lubricants to enhance razor movement while also protecting the skin, leaving it smooth and exfoliated. It leaves a pleasant scent and turns into thick cream when applied on wet skin—making it easy to spread to the most necessary areas.

Made for stubbles and full beards alike, this formulation will make your grooming routine much more enjoyable. This is simply one of the best men’s shaving creams for sensitive skin.

Who is this for? Every guy who has sensitive skin with thick or thin hair will appreciate that this gel is made specifically for your skin type.

Flaws but not deal-breakers: The scent may be too strong for some guys, especially since it tends to stick around after rinsing.

Form: Gel | Consistency: Thick | Size: 7 oz | Scent: Not specified | Skin type: Sensitive | Feature: Moisturizes, cools and soothes, reduces irritation

Why it’s great: The NIVEA Men Sensitive Shave Gel soothes sensitive skin through its non-drying alcohol formula. It can effectively fight irritation from shaving, burning, micro cuts, dryness, and stubble itches. The gel even improves razors’ swift movements and softens stubble for a close, tight shave.

Its vitamin E, natural chamomile, and witch hazel extract promote resilient and radiant facial features. It’s even an appropriate aftershave treatment with its prominent scent. You can use it to shave your head, beard, and other body parts with no problem.

Who is this for? Guys with ultra-sensitive skin will love that this is free of alcohol, which can have a damaging impact on the skin.

Flaws but not deal-breakers: Although this is one of the best men’s shaving creams for sensitive skin, it does have an extremely strong smell, which may be too much for some guys.

Form: Gel | Consistency: Thick | Size: 7 oz | Scent: Light Scent | Skin type: Dry/Sensitive | Feature: Fights irritation, improves razor glide

Why it’s great: The Art of Shaving is known for making some of the finest shaving (obviously) products. The Sandalwood Shaving Cream and its price tag are worth the investment. It’s certainly one of the best men’s shaving creams for sensitive skin.

When used, it creates a rich, thick lather that protects the skin from irritation and when mixed in a shaving bowl, it’ll create a luscious blob of thick cream that you can spread all over your full beard. The thick layer will help the glide of even the dullest blades you own.

Its sandalwood scent is naturally pleasant and subtly stays on your skin after the shave. Men with sensitive skin can use this cream worry-free, as it’s clinically tested to work. It’s also free from harmful chemicals that typically cause irritation and allergic reactions.

Who is this for? If you’re willing to splurge on the best of the best, then this is for you. The nice touches like coconut acid and essential oils make this one of the highest-end creams you can get.

Flaws but not deal-breakers: It has a slight tingling sensation from the sandalwood, which is to be expected.

Form: Cream | Consistency: Thick | Size: 5 oz | Scent: Sandalwood | Skin type: Dry/Sensitive | Feature: Reduces inflammation, smooths and softens skin

Why it’s great: The Gillette Series 3X Action Shave Gel comes in packs of two on Amazon for under $6. Try to beat that. Infused with aloe, it lubricates sensitive skin and prevents irritation.

It’s also lightly scented to give your nose (and your lady) a small treat as you shave. The thick lather it produces will minimize the risk of nicks and cuts during even the most intense shaves, and it gives razors a smooth, frictionless action.

Who is this for? If you need shaving cream and you need it ASAP, then go for this option. It also has Prime’s free two-day shipping.

Flaws but not deal-breakers: This is one of the best men’s shaving creams for sensitive skin. However, the minty scent and tingle may not be every guy’s cup of tea.

Form: Gel | Consistency: Thick | Size: 7 oz | Scent: Light Scent | Skin type: Dry/Sensitive | Feature: Protects against irritation, softens hair

Why it’s great: The Cremo Barber Grade Sensitive Shave Cream provides men with a tight shave every day of the week. It provides an ultra-slick surface when mixed with water, and the highly concentrated formula contains an essential oil blend that calms the skin and fights razor burn.

Each bottle lasts 90 days, which makes this ideal for daily use and a great value. The strong cooling action is ideal during hot weather, and the non-existent scent won’t make you queasy if you’re not a fan of fragrance.

If you shave every day, then you’ll also appreciate the convenience of the squeeze bottle, which makes your chore feel a little less taxing.

Who is this for? This is one of the best men’s shaving creams for sensitive skin. It’s ideal for men who shave their hair more than the average guy.

Work and leisure travelers will also appreciate the portability of the bottle—just be sure to keep the contents under the TSA limit of 3.4 ounces.

Flaws but not deal-breakers: The cream may take a bit longer to rinse off because of its slickness.

Form: Cream | Consistency: Thick | Size: 6 oz | Scent: Unscented | Skin type: Dry/Sensitive | Feature: Soothes skin, fights nicks, razor burn, and irritation

Why it’s great: Extra cautious men and tree huggers can take comfort in the fact that the Pacific Shaving Company Natural Shaving Cream has no artificial ingredients. Made from safe, plant-derived ingredients, it gives men with sensitive skin the best shave possible minus the razor burns or scary-sounding chemicals.

It also sports a convenient formula, as a small drop is enough to lather up a full face. The cream spreads easily, lessening the need for reapplication during one shave. And, it has a nice mixture of earthy trees and light herbs.

Who is this for? If you’re tired of mass-produced creams and complex chemicals, then this is for you. It’s one of the best men’s shaving creams for sensitive skin.

Flaws but not deal-breakers: It has a thin, runny liquid texture compared to other brands that are more foamy and thick.

Form: Cream | Consistency: Thick | Size: 7 oz | Scent: Natural | Skin type: Dry/Sensitive | Feature: Fights redness, irritation, and bumps

Buying Considerations For the Best Men’s Shaving Creams For Sensitive Skin

Ingredients

The ingredients matter a lot when you’re choosing the best men’s shaving creams for sensitive skin. The last thing you want is to trigger allergic reactions or irritation, so you’ll most likely need brands that are free from harmful chemicals. Thankfully, most brands are moving towards that these days.

Brands that use only organic ingredients may be the best place to look, and if you like to smell great after a long shave, then you might prefer scented cream and gels.

Consistency

Consistency also plays a vital role in selecting the best men’s shaving creams for sensitive skin. If you like the feeling of lotion on your face, then go for straight creams or gels. Foams, on the other hand, can produce a thicker, more voluminous lather when rubbed through the beard.

It all depends on your personal preference and how comfortable you’d like your shaving experience to be.

Scent

You want your shaving sessions to be as enjoyable as possible, and sometimes a fragrant scent is all you need to make it more relaxing. A mid-to-heavy-scented cream is nice for a pleasant shave, but if you’re the type of guy who prefers no smells, then organic products might suit your fancy.

How We Chose

Most shaving brands claim that their cream produces the best results and offers the most skin protection, but in reality, no one product solves everything for everyone. Some work best for ultra-sensitive skin, and others are more natural and cater to different people.

Keeping this in mind, I thoroughly read through customer reviews and product descriptions to find the best men’s shaving creams for sensitive skin that will fit the right person based on these factors:

Purpose: Is the shaving cream scented for an aromatic experience? Does it create a thick consistency for burly beards? I looked for shaving creams that were geared toward a specific individual’s needs and selected them for that category—not creams that claimed to be the only solution for every beard or skin type.

Customer Reviews: With a product as important as shaving cream, customer reviews are one of the key indicators of an effective product. I made these selections only if real men who used the product daily would recommend it to their friends.

Ingredients: Shaving creams, and skincare products broadly, are historically known to have ingredients that may cause further irritation. I aimed to include trusted brands and creams with quality, natural ingredients.

Why Trust Us?

Joe Niehaus has been researching and testing products for several years at other notable publications like Travel + Leisure and The Adult Man. He uses these products every day in his life, so he wants to make sure that guys everywhere are attuned to the best brands and ingredients on the market.

Joe’s diligent approach to finding the best men’s shaving creams for sensitive skin includes testing products in hand, checking their ingredients list, and working with industry experts to find what matters for the typical man.

His readers then get reliable first-hand experience and fitted recommendations, not just generic descriptions—ultimately helping readers make informed buying decisions based on real-life customer reviews.

Final Verdict

The best men’s shaving creams for sensitive skin should be free from harmful ingredients that irritate the skin while also providing a comfortable, relaxing shave.

The Edge Store Shave Gel For Men is my top choice because of its refreshing scent and ability to lather up into cream foam quickly. It enhances razor glide and offers serious skin protection. On top of that, it has more than 25,000 positive reviews on Amazon.