Forget the Fed. Forget nonfarm employment. Forget even industrial production and real income. For Jim Paulsen, the real recession indicator is watching Walmart.
Paulsen, the former chief investment strategist at investment research firm Leuthold Group, devised an indicator he dubs the “Walmart Recession Signal” (WRS), which tracks the stock price of Walmart against the S&P Global Luxury Index, a basket of 80 companies producing or distributing luxury goods. He said that since economic downturns are usually felt first by lower-income individuals, an increase in Walmart stock price could indicate a potential economic downturn.
Paulsen wrote in a Substack post that the indicator is now at its highest level since the 2008 Great Recession. “‘Walmart Worries’ just keep multiplying,” he wrote. “It’s currently close to the highest level ever recorded which was during the Great Financial Crisis of 2008-09.”
The central premise of the WRS is this: During economic downturns, consumers tend to shift their spending toward discount vendors like Walmart, and away from luxury retailers. It’s one way households cut down on costs when economic pressure is high. “As economic activity slows and recession risk builds, retailing purchasing patterns tend to gravitate toward discounters like Walmart and away from luxury retailers,” he wrote.
Walmart stock has climbed steadily over the past year, up over 40% year over year to $123.95 as of Tuesday afternoon. While the S&P Global Luxury Index is up over 7.7% year over year to $5,544.98, the price has fallen 13.6% since the beginning of the year.
The economy has sat in an increasingly precarious position as a string of back-to-back shocks has rattled it. A dismal February jobs report revealed the economy unexpectedly shed 92,000 jobs, and the unemployment rate crept up to 4.5%. The Iran war has only added to the economic pressure weighing on Americans as oil and fertilizer prices are skyrocketing. Gas prices just surpassed $4 a gallon. On top of that, the housing market faces a dire affordability crisis, and consumer sentiment remains grim.
All of these factors are crystallizing into a greater likelihood of a recession. Moody’s Analytics just raised its recession outlook for the next 12 months to 48.6%. That follows an increase from Goldman Sachs, which sets the likelihood to 30%. And EY-Parthenon sets the odds of a recession at 40%.
“I’m concerned recession risks are uncomfortably high and on the rise,” said Mark Zandi, chief economist at Moody’s Analytics. “Recession is a real threat here.”
Walmart’s booming year and heightened recession odds
Walmart, which held the number one spot on the Fortune 500 for 13 years before it was overtaken by Amazon in February, has had a booming year. The company posted revenue of $190.7 billion last quarter, up 5.6% from a year ago. Revenue for the full year was up 4.7% to $713.2 billion.
Paulsen said the WRS has had a close historical relationship with both annual real GDP growth and the unemployment rate. During successive economic downturns throughout the 90s and 21st century, the WRS rose before real GDP growth collapsed. He adds that every increase in unemployment has been preceded by an uptick in the WRS.
As for the causes of what’s impacting the WRS, Paulsen cites the cratering consumer sentiment, dismal job postings, the impact of the Iran war, among other factors. He also warns that instead of a public credit crisis, the economy may be facing a private credit crisis, as the WRS also has a close historical relationship with the value of private credit.
Yet Paulsen isn’t betting on a recession happening just yet, saying the U.S. may be in the clear this year.
But he adds “I am becoming more convinced that a significant U.S. economic slowdown is unfolding that will ultimately require additional economic policy accommodation and lower interest rates to arrest.”
